Skip to main content

The Maid's Room // Book review


Hodder very kindly contacted me a while back asking if I would like to be part of the blog tour for the paperback release of Fiona Mitchell's The Maid's Room and I was absolutely ecstatic to jump at the chance! Now,I must apologize for the delay of the post due to some unexpected postal delays etc etc, but here we are!





Rating: 3.5/5



Plot:
Set in the blistering heat of Singapore, The Maid's Room follows the lives of two Filipina maids - sisters Dolly and Tala who are working hard to send money back home, and British ex-pat Jules who has left her job as a midwife to move to Singapore with husband David.

Told with humour, heart-breaking detail about daily life as a maid, and with an exhilarating spirit that is ultimately uplifting, this book will resonate with anyone who has struggled to have their voice heard.

Perfect for fans of The Help and The Invention of Wings.




My thoughts:
So, for full disclosure,I shall start by letting you know that I did have some doubts going into this book because it very obviously has two women of colour at the center of it while the author herself is white.Those doubts did intensify a little when I found it quite hard to come across own voices reviews and wasn't quite sure what attitude to have while going into the book since I,myself,wouldn't be able to tell just how authentic the representation is.
ALAS.
In the end, I was impressed by how close to the subject Fiona Mitchell was after reading her explanation of what sparked her desire to tell this story and how it was inspired by real life events she witnessed/took part in.From what I could tell (tough you should obviously take my two cents on it with a grain of salt since I am in no place to be the voice of a community that I am not part of) the representation came across as heartfelt and respectful.
The phrase 'perfect for fans of The Help' does add on some extra weariness (though it made it very easy for me to recommend the book today in the shop when a lady was looking for recs based on that one!) because there is a certain level of white saviour-ness that I would expect when that comparison is made and the addition of a white protagonist did add to my worries.
BOY WAS I ECSTATIC TO BE WRONG! Fiona Mitchell makes it so that these wome -both Tala and Dolly,our protagonists,but also all the other maids that they are friends with- are complex,human characters as opposed to stereotypes and bland cardboard characters that lack dimension. Moreover, the book in itself presents these women taking agency and being the ones in charge of their own destinies despite their detrimental living conditions.
Which brings me to my main point, which is that I thoroughly appreciate Fiona Mitchell shining light on the real problem: though it is easy to lose yourself in Tala and Dolly's stories and to treat the whole thing like fiction, just like the women in this story commenting on the world The Help features so like their own, it is important to point out that to many women stories like this are a reality and not fiction.This makes me truly appreciate The maid's room and the intent behind the book.
The writing style is fastpaced,engaging and very heartfelt, which made it very easy to fly through the book in a couple of seatings.
That being said, there was still a little je ne sais quoi missing, which is why the book was more of a 3.5-3.75 for me.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PAPER LANTERNS ISSUE 3 // review

Paper Lanterns is a new literary journal, founded in 2020 by Grace Kelley, Ruth Ennis and Amy O’Sullivan, to be published four times a year. Acting as a platform to promote the voices of young people in Ireland and across the world, this journal provides new and exciting content for a teen and young adult audience. It is also perfect for enthusiasts of teen and YA literature; from teachers and librarians, to parents and youth workers. This is a YA journal for writers, artists, dreamers, and doers. This is a space for the underrepresented voices and a platform for publishing and promoting young writers and artists so they are seen and heard. We also make space for those who were once young adults to submit their work! Those who proudly and loudly represent young voices in today’s world. (Paper Lanterns) by Rebecca Johnson and cover design by Eleanor Braydon   Yet another stellar issue from Paper Lanterns ! If you were to check my previews reviews , it'd be easily apparent that I am
1 comment
Read more

PAPER LANTERNS ISSUE #2 review

― About Paper Lanterns     Paper Lanterns is a new literary journal, founded in 2020 by Grace Kelley, Ruth Ennis, and  Amy O’Sullivan, to be published four times a year. Acting as a platform to promote the voices  of young people in Ireland and across the world , this journal provides new and exciting content for a teen and young adult audience . It is also perfect for enthusiasts of teen and YA literature, from teachers and librarians, to parents and youth workers. The journal is divided into three sections. Our  literature, from teachers and librarians, to parents and youth workers.      The journal is divided into three sections. Our Creative Writing section showcases work from talented teens, as well as work from adult writers of teen and YA literature, tied in with beautiful artwork and photography. The  talented teens, as well as work from adult writers of teen and YA literature, tied in with  beautiful artwork and photography. The Features and Articles section includes unique es
Post a Comment
Read more

"All the bright places" by Jennifer Niven ~ Review

Rating:   5/5 Plot: I'm not quite sure what it is that I could share about the plot so that I don't give away too much and ruin the charm of the story and the pleasure of getting to know the characters and their story not knowing much about them beforehand.I think I'm trying to do that a lot nowadays. To put it as plainly as possible,it's honestly as simple as it promises,it's the story of a girl who learns how to live from a boy who wants to die.However simple and complicated at the same time this might sound,it doesn't even start to cover everything,yet perfectly describes it. !warning:  there's a lot of talk about suicide in the book,so if you find that triggering,please do try and avoid getting to it Thoughts on the book: It's hard to even figure out where to start talking about this book,this is how big of an impact it had on me,so I guess I'll just start at the beginning. Once again,I've made the mistake (because this i
2 comments
Read more